The Forgotten Subway: How a Secret Underground Revolution Began in New York

10:09 am  |  12.10.2025

In 1870, inventor Alfred Ely Beach stunned New York’s elite by unveiling a secret pneumatic subway tunnel beneath Broadway, challenging the city’s transportation infrastructure and political resistance through an audacious demonstration of engineering prowess.


Long before New York’s official subway system emerged, a visionary inventor named Alfred Ely Beach had already conceived and secretly constructed an underground marvel that would become a blueprint for urban transit.

On February 26, 1870, Beach orchestrated an extraordinary event in the basement of Devlin’s clothing store in Tribeca. He invited the city’s most influential figures to witness his revolutionary pneumatic subway – a project he had developed entirely without official permission.

A Technological Spectacle

Beach spared no expense in his presentation. The subway’s waiting room boasted a grand piano, elegant chandeliers, and a water fountain with live goldfish. The subway car itself was a marvel of luxury, featuring rich upholstery and innovative zirconia lighting.

Political Resistance

Despite the project’s ingenuity, powerful business interests – including stagecoach and horse-drawn streetcar operators – actively worked to block Beach’s vision. They reportedly paid political leaders like Boss Tweed to prevent the subway’s expansion.

Alfred Ely Beach: The Inventor Who Secretly Built NYC's First Underground Subway

A Visionary’s Legacy

Beach’s underground tunnel, approximately 300 feet long and eight feet wide, was more than just an engineering experiment. It was a strategic attempt to demonstrate the potential of urban mass transit by creating a working prototype that would capture public imagination.

Ultimately, Beach’s unauthorized subway remained a single-block demonstration. However, it planted the seed for New York’s future transit system, with the city’s first official subway line opening on October 27, 1904 – over three decades after Beach’s groundbreaking experiment.


“Beach built a complete working version of his concept, something that modern innovators have yet to achieve,” notes author Matthew Algeo.

Alfred Ely Beach: The Inventor Who Secretly Built NYC's First Underground Subway
Alfred Ely Beach: The Inventor Who Secretly Built NYC's First Underground Subway
See also  Shopping in New York: the Best Places to Spend Your Money

Like us on Facebook for more stories like this: